I think I MIGHT have gotten it to work... crossing my fingers. I re-downloaded a different client, and tried again - it's slowly (very, very slowly) downloading HIMYM S1 - so hopefully it will continue until finished. I'm trying not to jinx it ;)

Thank you for the link! I'm not sure how much help it will be (I haven't had a chance to really look at it yet) as I can't download u torrent since they don't make it for mac. But maybe some of the problems/solutions will be the same? I'll definitely check it out.

Also (totally unrelated): Do my eyes deceive me, or have you not signed up for Cuddy Fest? Because that's just not cool, man. SO NOT legendary.